Compare
Tank vs. Tankless Water Heaters in Phoenix
A tank is the right fit for most homes. For larger households, tankless costs less than a bigger tank and never runs out of hot water.
Tankless water heater $5,289 installed · 75-gal gas tank $3,889 installed
20-year cost
What each option costs over 20 years
Pick your household size and current water heater.
Tankless costs about $400 less per year, about $8,000 over 20 years.
| Cost | 75-Gal Gas Tank | Tankless Water Heater |
|---|---|---|
| Installed price | $3,889 | $5,289 |
| Average lifespan | 8 years | 20 years |
| Unit cost | $490/yr | $260/yr |
| Efficiency (UEF) | 0.59 | 0.95 |
| Avg. gas cost | $450/yr | $280/yr |
| Total cost per year | $940/yr | $540/yr |
| 20-year total | $18,800 | $10,800 |
Where the savings come from
Why tankless costs less over time
One water heater, not two
In Valley hard water a tank lasts 6 to 10 years. Tankless lasts 20 or more, so you buy once.
Lower gas bills
A tank keeps 50 gallons hot around the clock. Tankless heats water only when you turn on the tap.
Longer warranty
15-year heat exchanger warranty on tankless, compared with 6 years on a tank.
Beyond the math
More than savings
Endless hot water
Back-to-back showers and a running dishwasher, without running out.
More garage space
Mounts on the wall and frees up the floor where the tank stood.
No tank to leak
No 50 gallons of water waiting to spill into your garage or closet.
Being straight with you
When a tank still makes sense
You are selling soon
If you plan to move within a few years, you won’t be there for the savings.
Upfront cost comes first
A tank costs less to install today, and our tanks carry a 6-year warranty.
Smaller homes on a budget
For 1 to 4 people, tankless saves less each year, and a 50-gallon tank costs much less upfront.
Assumptions
How we calculated this
- Natural gas at $1.59 per therm (Southwest Gas residential rate, Sep 2026). The monthly service charge is the same either way, so it is left out.
- Electricity at $0.154 per kWh (Arizona residential average, U.S. Energy Information Administration, Jul 2026).
- Hot water use of 35, 60 and 85 gallons a day for 1–2, 3–4 and 5+ people.
- Water heated from 72°F, the year-round average for Valley tap water, to 120°F.
- Efficiency ratings (UEF) of 0.93 for a 50-gallon electric tank, 0.63 for a 50-gallon gas tank, 0.59 for a 75-gallon gas tank and 0.95 for tankless, from manufacturer and ENERGY STAR listings.
- A tank is replaced every 8 years in Valley hard water. Tankless lasts 20 years.
- Gas prices rise 3% a year; the yearly gas cost shown is the average over 20 years.
- Unit cost per year is the installed price divided by average lifespan. The 20-year total is the yearly total times 20.
- Both types need a yearly flush, so maintenance is the same and left out. Repairs are not included.
- Unit cards on the Replacement page are each figured for the household that unit is sized for, shown on the card. “Total cost” per year is the installed price divided by average lifespan, plus the yearly gas or electric cost averaged over 20 years.
These are estimates. Your actual gas use depends on your household’s habits.
FAQ
Tank vs. tankless questions
Is tankless worth it in Phoenix?
Yes, for most homes with 5 or more people. Tankless costs less per year than a 75-gallon tank and never runs out of hot water. For 1–4 people the yearly savings are smaller, so a 50-gallon tank is often the better value upfront.
Will one tankless unit keep up with my home?
Our tankless unit runs two showers at once in most Valley homes. Warm supply water here helps it keep up.
Does tankless need maintenance?
Yes. Valley hard water builds scale, so we recommend a yearly descaling flush. Tanks need a yearly flush too.
Can you switch my gas tank to tankless?
Yes, in most homes. If your gas line or venting needs an upgrade, you’ll know the cost before we arrive.
What if I have an electric water heater?
Our tankless unit runs on natural gas. Call or text us and we’ll tell you what switching would take.
Need a new water heater or a repair?
Book online in about two minutes, or get an instant quote with your price locked for 14 days.
